Don't Miss Your Exit (and other lessons from an EV drive) | A New Shade of Green | Sherry Listgarten | Almanac Online |

Local Blogs

A New Shade of Green

By Sherry Listgarten

E-mail Sherry Listgarten

About this blog: Climate change, despite its outsized impact on the planet, is still an abstract concept to many of us. That needs to change. My hope is that readers of this blog will develop a better understanding of how our climate is evolving a...  (More)

View all posts from Sherry Listgarten

Don't Miss Your Exit (and other lessons from an EV drive)

Uploaded: Jul 14, 2019
Driving an EV to Tahoe? Don’t miss your exit! I learned this and other lessons from two round trips between Palo Alto and Tahoe City in a Chevy Bolt (1). Maybe you are thinking of getting an EV but are nervous about longer drives. Or maybe you have an EV and want to understand what impacts mileage. Or maybe you’d just like to understand a little more about EVs and what they show on their dashboards. Then this blog post is for you!

For EV newbies, a little terminology: A gas-powered car has a tank filled with gas. We fill up the car with gallons of gas, and we talk about efficiency in terms of “miles per gallon”. An electric car has a battery instead of a tank. So we fill up the car (charge the car) with kilowatt-hours (kWh) and we talk about efficiency in terms of “miles per kWh”. So the concepts are pretty similar, as shown in this table:


The Chevy Bolt has a relatively large battery (60 kWh) and an estimated range of around 240 miles. The dashboard has a gauge that shows how “full” the battery is, just like the gauge in a gas-powered car. You can see the gauge on the left emptying in this series of pictures from one of the drives.


The Bolt provides more detailed information about mileage and capacity than a traditional car if you choose the “enhanced” display (shown above). It gives an estimate of how many miles are left, with an upward green indicator if mileage is improving (left picture), or a downward yellow indicator if mileage is decreasing (middle picture). The number on the right of the dashboard shows real-time power consumption (e.g., 14 kW in the left picture). If you accelerate quickly, the number is much higher (e.g., 40 kW). Imagine knowing how much gas you are burning at any given moment in a gas-powered car!

So how did the drives go? Below is a summary of the four trips between Palo Alto (PA) and Tahoe City (TC).


Mileage was much better than I expected, even though I made little effort to drive efficiently. I had to charge the car once on each trip to Tahoe City, but not on the way back. The overall trip times were fine -- there wasn’t much traffic, and the charging stops took about 35 minutes. I was impressed. But I learned some things along the way...

Mileage varies a lot
The car takes a snapshot of its mileage every five miles. Here is a chart showing the variation on the drive to Tahoe.


Mileage varies from under 2 mi/kWh to 16 mi/kWh. So if the battery has 5 kWh left, you might go just another 10 miles or you might last 40. You can see the mileage dropping as the grade increases just after Auburn (around 150 miles). The Bolt’s battery neared empty right around the steepest part of the climb. Which brings me to my next point.

Don’t miss your exit
I used PlugShare to find exits with fast chargers, located every 10-20 miles on 80 past Auburn. The first trip up was pretty straight-forward. I stopped at Nyack Road with about 30 miles left, charged for 30 minutes while I walked the dog, then kept going. No problem. So I wasn’t paying as much attention the second trip up. I had used up more battery than the first trip, due to being routed through Livermore, but I knew I could make it to the same stop, which I remembered was in Emigrant Gap. Unfortunately, I was looking for the Emigrant Gap exit (no charger) instead of Nyack Road (charger). I drove past Nyack Road about the same time I realized that was my exit. My battery was nearly empty (less than 10 miles left), and exits are generally spaced far apart on this stretch of 80. I briefly panicked until I realized that, luckily, the actual Emigrant Gap exit wasn’t much farther. I got to that exit, turned around, and rolled into Nyack Road with just a few miles to spare.

The car gave a series of battery warnings, as shown here.

This is the first low-battery warning -- the gauge turned orange.



When the estimated miles left dropped farther, the dashboard spelled out a warning.



When the battery dropped even farther, it stopped showing miles remaining and limited acceleration, displaying “Propulsion Power is Reduced”. In my case, though, the car slowed down because I realized I just passed the exit with the charger and was wondering what to do...



At this point there was just one bar left on the battery gauge. The dash didn’t change, but I have sped up. I saw a sign indicating the next exit isn’t that far after all. I knew I could make it.



The battery gauge went completely blank a short while later. Even though I was confident I had enough battery, the dashboard was doing its best to unnerve me.



Finally, the radio display disappeared, indicating that the radio and other non-essentials were going to be disabled. The “infotainment” display went dark, and could only be re-enabled by pushing on a manual button.



The Chevy Bolt takes running out of battery very seriously!

The cost of charging an EV on the road is often opaque and can be high
While I feel like the Bolt has my back on a drive, I don’t have that warm and fuzzy feeling about the charging infrastructure.

When you pay at the pump for gas, you generally know what it is going to cost you. You are charged by the gallon, so all you really need to know is how many gallons you will pump.

Many commercial EV chargers don’t work that way. Instead of charging per kWh, they charge per time! Since some pumps are faster than others, and advertised rates are not always truthful, it can be hard to know what you will end up paying.

In the case of the Nyack Road station, they advertise 50 kW chargers. Here is a screenshot from the EVGo charging app.



A 50 kW charger should put 25 kWh of charge on an empty battery in 30 minutes. (4) But it only added 17.5 kWh. And this happened twice. This charger only has 35 kW of power. Luckily I didn’t have far to go so I didn’t need more than that.

The city of Palo Alto charges about 19 cents per kWh for electricity. This pump charges 86 cents per kWh! You can think of that in terms of gas prices. A gallon of gas might cost $4 and last 30 miles. That is 13 cents per mile. If an EV goes about 4 miles per kWh, then this station is charging 21 cents per mile, which is similar to $6.50 for a gallon of gas(!) In contrast, charging an EV at home would cost less than 5 cents per mile, similar to $1.50 for a gallon of gas.

I hope that pricing becomes more transparent over time. Some new regulations on public EV chargers are being considered, addressing this and some other issues (e.g., many do not accept a credit card).

Your mileage may vary
A number of factors affect mileage besides incline. The Bolt keeps track of four of them throughout the trip: driving technique, terrain, climate control, and outside temperature. Here is a picture of the dashboard at the end of the first (uphill) trip to Tahoe City. You can see that the uphill drive (“terrain”) and my insistence on driving at speed uphill (“technique”) contributed to a loss of over 25 miles from expected mileage.



In contrast, the downhill drive added about 30 miles of range. (I’m not sure why “technique” is favorable. Maybe there were just fewer opportunities for me to drive inefficiently, given so much downhill.)



It’s interesting to look at the second downhill trip as well. My technique was worse than the first downhill trip, leading to poorer mileage (4.5 mi/kWh instead of 4.7) despite the trip being identical. I think I was just going faster.



It’s fine to use the AC
As you can see from the pictures above, warm temperatures ("outside temperature") improve mileage. Running the AC ("climate settings") reduced the mileage, but not as much as the warmer temperatures helped. So I would not hesitate to use the car’s AC on a warm day. I can imagine, in contrast, that cold days are problematic. The battery would already be running less efficiently, and heating the car would exacerbate that. That is why Chevrolet advises turning on the heated seats and steering wheel on cold days, rather than using the more power-hungry forced-air heat.

Inflate your tires
For some reason, the mileage on this trip was much better than I expected. I have been averaging about 3.5 on a normal highway trip, and here I averaged 3.6 or 3.7 on an uphill, largely highway trip. The only thing I can attribute that to, besides the warmer temperatures, is tire pressure. The recommended pressure for this car is 38 psi, but my tires were 34-35 on previous trips. I don’t think tire pressure is supposed to make a particularly big difference -- a few percentage points in mileage -- but I figure it helped some. I also found a cute dashboard display.



Tire pressure went up during the trip, probably due to warmer tires:



And lots more
Here are a few other things I observed. You can also look at the raw data here if you are interested.

- It is fun to watch your “gas tank” fill up as you are driving. Because EVs recharge the battery when braking, and because the Bolt has an option of doing this even when you don’t explicitly brake, the battery seems to magically refill as you are driving on long downhill stretches. You can see the long downhill stretch in this chart, starting around mile 30 (Donner Summit) down to about mile 90 (Loomis).


- It is nice to get to a beautiful place like Tahoe and consider that you got there by driving on sunshine. I know that is an exaggeration; there was certainly some fossil fuel in the power mix, though I charge my battery midday. And of course there are lifecycle emissions of the car, asphalt on the roads, etc.... But it’s a nice thing to contemplate.

- A lot of thought seems to have gone into the various estimates that the dashboard shows. For example, the display of how many miles are left adjusts up and down depending on factors like how you are driving and the overall terrain. It seems to work pretty well. After driving over 60 miles towards home from Tahoe City, the estimated miles left had actually gone up from 221 to 228, due to much downhill terrain. Similarly, on a long uphill stretch after Auburn, the estimated mileage plummeted from 100 to 18 miles, though I’d driven less than 50 miles.

The efficiency estimates also seem pretty good. For example, the car estimated a 55 mile difference in range between the uphill and downhill drives. The actual energy consumption differed by about 14.8 kWh, which at 4 miles/kWh is 59 miles -- pretty close!

There is a lot of EV expertise in this area. I’m interested to hear your take on how they operate or what is changing, and your experience with longer trips. The worst story I heard was of a guy who drove his EV to see the eclipse and missed it because all the charging stations were full…

Dedication

This post is dedicated to the memory of Laurie Naiman, this blog’s #1 fan and one of my parents’ oldest friends. Laurie was a big fan of the Weekly and a frequent participant in (and winner of) its photo contests. He was also an EV enthusiast and would have enjoyed this post more than most. My family will cherish the memory of his wit, warmth, and wisdom.

Notes and References

1. The Chevy Bolt has a pretty big battery (60 kWh) and can go a good distance (200+ miles) without a charge. This car also accommodates a fast (level 3) charger, which not all EVs do. The big battery and fast charger were essential for making this a fast and easy trip.

2. Yes, that is a big range of electricity prices! This post explains how prices (on the road) can get so high. Electricity prices at home are more like 15-20 cents per kWh.

3. The first trip (PA to TC via SF) had a short 3-mile, 10-minute or so detour near the start.

4. One problem with the Chevy Bolt’s fast charging is that it becomes much less fast once the battery is about 60-70% full. So you can only “fast charge” when it is relatively empty, and you cannot “fast charge” to a full charge.

5. Now that I think about it, “Don’t miss your exit” applies for any type of vehicle on 80 if you are going to run as low as I did on fuel. The issue wasn’t so much a lack of chargers as it was that I drove to near-empty, using the detailed vehicle information. I wouldn’t have done that in a gas car because the information wouldn’t have been available. But some people do. So the lesson is really “If you are going to run your car to near empty, don’t miss the re-fueling exit.” Which you probably already knew…

6. For those of you who don’t have an EV, you should know that in practice you just need to look at the battery gauge periodically, just like you’d look at a gas gauge. All this other information is available but not really necessary.

Current Climate Data (May/June 2019)

Remember that reducing your transportation emissions is the #1 thing you can do in this area!

Global impacts, US impacts, CO2 metric, Climate dashboard (updated annually)

Comment Guidelines

I hope that your contributions will be an important part of this blog. To keep the discussion productive, please adhere to these guidelines, or your comment may be moderated:
- Avoid disrespectful, disparaging, snide, angry, or ad hominem comments.
- Stay fact-based, and provide references (esp links) as helpful.
- Stay on topic.
- In general, maintain this as a welcoming space for all readers.

What is community worth to you?
Support local journalism.

Comments

 +   2 people like this
Posted by Resident, a resident of Another Palo Alto neighborhood,
on Jul 14, 2019 at 7:25 am

The other thing to remember with charging stations is that it makes a difference how many cars are being charged at the same time. If there is only one car, that car will receive the full potential of the charging station. If there are two cars being charged, that potential will diminish. So if you think you received a fast charge at a certain charging station and make a mental note that it is a good choice for using again, it may be different depending on the total number of cars being charged at any one time.


 +   2 people like this
Posted by Leaf owner, a resident of Old Palo Alto,
on Jul 14, 2019 at 7:36 am

Leaf owner is a registered user.

This is an extremely helpful and informative post. Thank you for all the data and clear explanation.

Our Leaf was in the initial batch of Leafs sold in California and we love it. But the mileage on a full charge has dwindled significantly over the years and now we must limit our use to around town. We can't reliably get to San Jose or San Francisco and back on a full charge, and find that recharging in either city isn't a good option. There is too much uncertainty about the availability of a charging station where we need it.

I'm wondering what will become of these early EVs as their batteries make them less useful. Will there be a re-sale market? Is it practical and economical to replace the battery? What will happen to EVs as the original owners upgrade to new EVs?


 +   3 people like this
Posted by Max Hauser, a resident of Mountain View,
on Jul 14, 2019 at 12:33 pm

Max Hauser is a registered user.

First: This is an awesomely researched and documented blog, Sherry. It stands out [redacted] for sheer volume of diligent information, thoughtfully presented. Deserves one of those national journalism awards IMO (if there's a "journalistic blog" category). And you are even doing direct research yourself (the capture of en-route trip data displayed in the current blog above).

Second, "Leaf owner" above raised a broad topic that may not be widely enough known among EV owners (or potential owners). Batteries are electrochemical devices with not just finite lifetimes but a tendency to "aging" and loss of some energy-storage capacity over time. This may improve with technology, and it also can be influenced by number and depth of charge-discharge cycles, but aging is a general characteristic of rechargeable batteries of all kinds. It's another distinction from fuel-powered vehicles -- as Leaf owner's comment above illustrates, a bit like having a gas tank that very gradually shrinks, and may eventually need replacement.


 +   2 people like this
Posted by akaMaiNguyen, a resident of Greenmeadow,
on Jul 14, 2019 at 2:42 pm

akaMaiNguyen is a registered user.

Hello Leaf owner,
I bought a second-hand 2011 Leaf two years ago. The first owner said that the original battery went below six bars after five years of use, and he was able to replace it with a new battery from Nissan. We have been very happy with this 2011 Leaf with a 2106 battery. We have heard that the quality of Nissan batteries has improved after the first few years. So far, the new battery still has its full twelve bars. The not so good news is that we heard Nissan has recently raised their replacement battery price, to $7000, and labor and tax needed on top of that. So once this second battery dies, hopefully after many more years of use, we're likely to retire the car and get the battery recycled.


 +   2 people like this
Posted by eileen , a resident of another community,
on Jul 14, 2019 at 4:11 pm

I loved reading this. I have a 2016 Chevy Spark EV which I bought used with 300 miles, after leasing a 2014 Spark EV for 3 years. Dealership got the rebate and then didn't have a use for the car, I guess. Anyway, my little Chevy dashboard provides some but not all of the information the Bolt does. Now I know that because, after reading the blog, I spent some time looking. NO WAY can I drive to Tahoe, but the car is fine for driving locally.
Of note, Laurie Naiman was an amazing guy, brilliant photographer, and dear friend. He was one of the first to have an electric car and solar panels on his roof. He and his wife were trend setters in green thinking.


 +   1 person likes this
Posted by Sherry Listgarten, a Almanac Online blogger,
on Jul 15, 2019 at 10:43 am

Sherry Listgarten is a registered user.

Thanks for the great comments! A couple of questions/comments.

@Resident -- Yeah, I was wondering about that. I don’t know how much power is required for (say) a 4-station 50 kW charger setup. 200 kW? 150? 100? How do they “certify” the chargers if they are underprovisioned? (Is there a certification?) Eesh, there is lots to understand here…

@Leaf owner -- Great question! First of all, congrats and thank you for being an early adopter of EVs. I think there must be a big market for used EVs, and soon, if they are going to be adopted in the numbers that we need. And that means we need a better market around batteries. One interesting thing I saw, after you asked the question and @aka chimed in with the high cost of battery replacement, is that Nissan is offering refurbished batteries for about half the price of new ones, starting in Japan. That seems like a terrific idea. I’ve also seen battery leases, which is an interesting idea. I would expect to see a lot of innovation in battery sales in the near future.

@Max -- Yes! It’s almost like you are buying a car and a battery, not just a car, and you need to consider them both. I was really interested to read (link above) that Renault sold cars without batteries, then leased the battery. Interesting!


 +  Like this comment
Posted by sequoiadean, a resident of Los Altos,
on Jul 16, 2019 at 10:40 am

sequoiadean is a registered user.

Very interesting, Sherry, I loved seeing all your screen shots here as you describe the drives. I don't have an EV now (my wife and I have shared just 1 car for the past 2 years), but I'm sure we'll eventually have one, especially if we end up ever needing a second car!


 +  Like this comment
Posted by Nemo, a resident of Professorville,
on Jul 16, 2019 at 4:53 pm

Nemo is a registered user.

Very informative article. Another factor that affects economy on the highway is the wind. If you're dutifully keeping the speedo at 55-60 to conserve energy, but you're driving into a 10mph headwind, you're effectively driving at 65-70. A tailwind has the opposite effect, and of course both affect fossil burners in the same way. You can see if there's some wind by looking at trees, but flags are better direction indicators. You can also pay attention to the wind noise you hear in the car. Seems high? Likely headwind.


 +  Like this comment
Posted by Novelera, a resident of Midtown,
on Jul 16, 2019 at 5:09 pm

Novelera is a registered user.

Thanks SO much for the excellent information!! I'm driving my last gas car that has a current mileage of 101,000. I've been very curious about travel range of EVs. It was also interesting to read about PlugShare. Way back in the early 80's I had a diesel VW Rabbit and nearly ran out of fuel a couple of times because diesel fuel wasn't at every filling station then. I think that sort of created anxiety about driving a long way with anything other than a standard gasoline engine.


 +  Like this comment
Posted by Sherry Listgarten, a Almanac Online blogger,
on Jul 17, 2019 at 11:00 am

Sherry Listgarten is a registered user.

Ooh, I love the concept “my last gas car” !!

@sequoia -- That is great about sharing a car. Several neighbors of mine are doing that, trading off biking and driving.

@nemo -- Good point about the wind, I’ll keep an eye out for that if my mileage seems off.

@novelera -- Makes sense! FWIW, I don’t think we’re out of the woods yet wrt long drives in these cars. According to these super useful charts, you get only about 150 miles after an hour of fast-charging the Bolt. That is not great. And winter driving and charging will be worse. I still have an “ICE” car (internal combustion engine) for winter drives to Tahoe. I’m hoping to hold out for another five years or so until EVs have improved, though we could also just rent one when needed...

Glad so many of you like the post, and that the photos are helpful.


 +  Like this comment
Posted by drizzle, a resident of Barron Park,
on Jul 17, 2019 at 11:13 am

drizzle is a registered user.

A FAQ about 'shared' or 'potentially under-provisioned' EV chargers
Web Link

I think shared chargers tend to be in the minority. The Chargepoint description of a station indicates 'shared' or not.
If not 'shared', then the station charges NN cars at full power concurrently.

The 'shared' attribute can affect $$, when the cost is by time $/hour. If it needs to reduce the power to your car, then you get less energy (kWH) for $/hour.


 +  Like this comment
Posted by Sherry Listgarten, a Almanac Online blogger,
on Jul 17, 2019 at 11:48 am

Sherry Listgarten is a registered user.

@drizzle -- Thanks! So, yeah, that writeup says that it does not recommend oversubscribing for hourly or short-term parking. Which makes sense, for the reasons you mention. Sounds like chargepoint tracks it, and it's uncommon for their installations, which is great. I don't know about others, though. I know that houses in general are oversubscribed -- when you add up the amperage on your appliances, it's more than your panel, because not everything is used at once. But it seems misleading at best to provision these charging stations assuming they will not be used simultaneously.

Thanks for the helpful reference!


 +  Like this comment
Posted by kpauls, a resident of Greenmeadow,
on Jul 19, 2019 at 12:21 pm

Really top notch post Sherry. You put a lot of work into this one and it is paying off for many people. I can't wait to get an EV.

My friend just had an unfortunate experience driving her Bolt from the bay area to Santa Barbara. I'll share this post with her and she may want to share her experience as well.

Thank you for doing this work, Sherry!


 +  Like this comment
Posted by Sherry Listgarten, a Almanac Online blogger,
on Jul 20, 2019 at 10:43 am

Sherry Listgarten is a registered user.

@kpauls It would be great if your friend would share her experience! I think doing long drives in the Bolt requires planning. It doesn't matter for us -- we don't do many long drives, and we have a regular car if we need to. But for people who must do many long drives in an EV, a Tesla is probably a better choice. There is a relevant story here, though the comments reflect a generally different point of view.


 +  Like this comment
Posted by neighbor, a resident of Midtown,
on Jul 21, 2019 at 8:08 pm

terrific post sherry...except for one thing: the title. most people will only glance at the title, and not bother to read what you wrote.

is the title the fault of palo alto online? your article is full of facts and narrative that encourage people to, as you say, reduce "your transportation emissions" which "is the #1 thing you can do". yet, so many will only see the title and be put off of considering an EV.

i apologize for being critical. your columns are so thought and upbeat and helpful. hopefully, the title will be as good as what you write from now on.

thanks so much, neighbor

ps - did you notice that stanford rep is doing an entire month of movies and plays about environmental justice?


 +  Like this comment
Posted by Sherry Listgarten, a Almanac Online blogger,
on Jul 22, 2019 at 9:53 pm

Sherry Listgarten is a registered user.

@neighbor -- Please don't worry about being critical! That is one way that we all learn, right?

I write the titles. The only thing the Weekly writes are the summaries that appear in the little "ads" they make for this blog from time to time.

I chose this title for two reasons. (1) Missing the exit was, for me, by far the most memorable part of these four drives. And (2) I thought it would intrigue many people and encourage them to read the post, or at least look at the pictures. I did consider that it might give some people the sense that EVs don't work well, particularly those looking for confirmation of existing opinions. But I felt the tradeoff (intriguing a number of people) was worth it. And I also do not think the Bolt is great for lots of long drives. A successful long drive takes planning and/or juggling devices while driving (e.g., to find chargers), and even some luck (e.g., finding empty chargers). So I am okay with the choice of title.

I'm not sure what to do about people who don't read. I know there are many of them. I do include pictures for that reason. Or per your suggestion, maybe Stanford Repertory Theater's program will find some of them...

I'm also not sure what to do about confirmation bias. It is pretty powerful, and I haven't read up on ways to address it.

Thanks again for the thoughtful comment.


Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

All your news. All in one place. Every day.

What gives you hope?
By Sherry Listgarten | 22 comments | 3,583 views

Shake Shack to open doors at San Mateo's Hillsdale Shopping Center this weekend
By Elena Kadvany | 1 comment | 1,509 views

‘Twas the Night Before Christmas
By Cheryl Bac | 0 comments | 603 views

Premarital and Couples: What feeling is not allowed, and what do you use in its place?
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 526 views

 

The holidays are here!

From live music to a visit with Santa, here's a look at some local holiday activities to help you get into the spirit of the season.

VIEW