News - November 2, 2011

Atherton residents create their own library survey

by Barbara Wood

Atherton residents, whose request to the City Council to survey the town about the location of a new library was not approved, have taken matters into their own hands and created their own survey.

According to former Atherton councilwoman Didi Fisher, a link to the online survey was emailed to 1,800 residents of Atherton on Monday evening, Oct. 24, and by Friday evening, 155 people had taken the survey.

The City Council decided by a 3-2 vote at its Oct. 19 meeting to choose town-owned Holbrook Palmer Park as the "preferred site" for a new library. Council members also voted unanimously to request a special meeting to discuss conducting a master plan study of town facilities and buildings. Petitions bearing at least 300 signatures asking for the master plan were presented to the council at the start of the meeting.

Many of the speakers at the packed meeting had also asked the town to conduct a survey, but the council did not request one.

The survey emailed Oct. 24 has 10 questions asking how well informed survey-takers are about the library issue, their views on usage of the park, how much they use town facilities, and demographic information.

The survey, perhaps to no one's surprise, shows how divided the town is about the library issue. A total of 54.8 percent of the respondents to the survey said they agreed or strongly agreed that the library should remain in the town center. A slightly larger percentage, 58.7 percent, said they agreed or strongly agreed the library "should not take up our limited park space."

A similar division took place on the question of library size. A little more than half the respondents, 50.3 percent said they agree or strongly agree that they like the Atherton library "small and quant the way it is." But even more said it "would be better with a little more space," with 62.8 percent saying they agree or strongly agree with that statement.

Just a little over half the respondents, 56.9 percent, said they "like Holbrook-Palmer Park the way it is."

Respondents to the survey were less divided on a few topics. A total of 78.1 percent said the town needs a master plan for all its buildings before making a final decision on the location of the library. A slightly lower percentage, 70.9 percent, said they want a town vote on where to move the library.

A large number of those who took the survey said they had been at least vaguely aware of the library issue before the recent council meeting on the topic — 74.2 percent said they were either vaguely aware, aware or participated in the issue.

Only 18.7 percent of those taking the survey said they have lived in Atherton fewer than 11 years, with 35.3 percent saying they have lived in the town between 11 and 20 years, and a robust 25.9 percent saying they have lived in Atherton more than 30 years.

Forty-two percent of the respondents said they have school-age children, while 38.5 percent said they are retired.

One of the survey questions that gained the most agreement might give hope to those embroiled in this issue. A total of 83.9 percent of those surveyed said they "love living in Atherton."

Visit to see the survey summary.


Posted by survey, a resident of Atherton: other
on Nov 4, 2011 at 6:35 pm

Here are some results from the survey. Responses 155. Highlights are that 70-75% want the town to vote on the issue and 20-30% agree with statements that Atherton wants a bigger library in the park. On several questions 15% or more had no opinion. With 70% of the survey opposed to the vote of the council to move the library and double its size, hopefully the council will listen to the Park and Recreation Committee and those that were surveyed and put this to a vote. To make it easier to read I am combining Strongly Disagree with Disagree and just calling it "Disagree". Also Strongly agree is combined with Agree and called "Agree".


I believe the library should remain

within the Town Center area

Disagree 20% (31) No Opinion 25% (39) Agree 55% (85)

I like the Atherton Library small and

quaint the way it is

Disagree 28.5% (45) No Opinion 20% (31) Agree 50% (77)

I think the library needs to be

substantially larger

Disagree 58% (88) No Opinion 18% (28) Agree 25% (37)

I like Holbrook-Palmer Park the way it is


23% (36) No Opinion 19% (30) Agree 57% (87)

Replacing the Main House with a

library is not the right thing for the


Disagree 21% (32) No Opinion 18% (27) Agree 61% (94

Do you believe that a public library

qualifies as a ''recreation'' use for a

park? Yes 29% (44) No Opinion 16% (25) no 55% (84)

The decision to move the library

should be made by a vote of town

residents Disagree 25% (38) No Opinion 5% (7) Agree 71% (110)

Posted by Pat Cooksey , a resident of Menlo Park: other
on Nov 6, 2011 at 10:17 am

I use the library and enjoy its atmosphere each time I enter it. I attended a computer class there which seemed to have ample room for participants.

I have never noticed the sound of the train while in the library.

I have never not been able to find close by parking on those occasions when I have driven instead of walked. The placement of the library is perfect as far as I am concerned.

I visit the park everyday on my walk. I cannot imagine tearing down the house in order to place a library there. The park is built around the house. When you walk in park, you are given a place of restful tranquility as you go around the loop. The people you see there are using the park, not rushing into the library to drop off a book or to use the computer or just use the library for an extended amount of time.

Please keep the two separated the way they are now.

I would hope that citizen voices are not only heard but listened to. I am wondering how this idea came up and once having been voiced why it has been taken to the point of a concrete proposal.

Opinion respectfully submitted by a user of both the library and park.

Don't miss out on the discussion!
Sign up to be notified of new comments on this topic.


Post a comment

Posting an item on Town Square is simple and requires no registration. Just complete this form and hit "submit" and your topic will appear online. Please be respectful and truthful in your postings so Town Square will continue to be a thoughtful gathering place for sharing community information and opinion. All postings are subject to our TERMS OF USE, and may be deleted if deemed inappropriate by our staff.

We prefer that you use your real name, but you may use any "member" name you wish.

Name: *

Select your neighborhood or school community: * Not sure?

Comment: *

Verification code: *
Enter the verification code exactly as shown, using capital and lowercase letters, in the multi-colored box.

*Required Fields